Perception is Not Reality

I couldn’t put my finger on it for sure. But it definitely happened.

There was definitely a time it was not okay to like Brett Favre.

With his enshrinement in the Pro Football Hall of Fame and, perhaps more significantly, https://i2.wp.com/larrybrownsports.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/Brett-Favre1.jpgbeing inducted into the Packers Hall of Fame (and his #4 retired), it seems like that time has definitely passed.

Actually that’s probably not fair. It seems like it’s been past for a while now. But with his recent inclusion in the most exclusive club available to football’s greatest, it seems that the time for hatred has officially ended.

But the weird part is I sometimes feel like the only one who remembers it existed at all. But, I mean, that can’t possibly be true, can it? I can’t be the only one who remembers when Favre was as easy to mock as Michael Jackson (back when it was okay to mock Michael Jackson) and the general internet consensus was he’d been reduced to a washed-up has-been who couldn’t play any more and probably never could if we’re being honest, and also he sent pictures of his dick to everyone. Or at least to one person.

Although actually to say that was only one time isn’t really fair, either. Well, okay, the dick pics only came up once, but much like Favre’s famous indecision regarding his retirement…s, the football-watching world could never seem to make up it’s mind about Favre.

Remember back in 2005 when Green Bay drafted Aaron Rodgers? For the next two years,

http://assets.nydailynews.com/polopoly_fs/1.1491012!/img/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/article_970/super-bowl-rodgers-renaissance-football.jpg

Without a doubt the dorkiest picture of two professional football players known to man.

all the reports ranged between saying Favre was gruff and unwelcoming to the rookie to flat-out calling him a terrible teammate. The fact that these two years happened to coincide with two of the worst in Favre’s career to that point is probably coincidence. Then, 2007, redemption. Favre led the upstart Packers to a surprising 13-3 record, putting up some of the best numbers of his career. Sports Illustrated declared him sportsperson of the year and did an article on what a mentor he was to Rodgers and the other QBs. Suddenly, Favre had become a good teammate.

For one year. The next year Favre got traded to New York, had a strong start to the season, but faded down the stretch as his new team missed the playoffs. ESPN officially declared him “locker room cancer.” The old reports resurfaced. Favre and Rodgers never got along. Favre never made Rodgers feel comfortable. Favre ripped the head off of kittens and ate the placenta of unborn children.

The thing is, the actual facts of those reports hardly changed at all, if you pushed deep enough to actually find them. Favre didn’t go out of his way to help Rodgers take his job, what Rodgers was obviously brought in to (eventually) do, but if Rodgers came to him looking for specific help, he’d provide it. We can debate all day about whether Favre should have made the younger player seek him out or if he should do more to be a “good” teammate, but the simple fact is the reports stayed virtually the same year-to-year, while the judgments and narratives in those news stories varied widely.

And that’s a pattern that holds true not with the little things, t00. Late in the 2009 season, Favre (now with the Vikings) had a Monday night game at the Chicago Bears. Leading up to the game, the story was the freezing cold conditions, and how Favre hadn’t won such a game in almost two years.

The Vikings sleepwalked through the first half, spotting Chicago 16 points, before ultimately falling behind 23-6 midway through the third quarter. But led by Favre and Adrian Peterson, nearly pulled off a comeback for the ages, coming all the way back to tie the game at 23, falling behind again, only to put together a 68-yard drive that ended when Favre hit Sidney Rice for a touchdown on fourth and goal with 16 seconds left in the game.Rice TD

Just before that score, one of the game’s announcers commented on all the claims that Favre could no longer play well in cold weather, saying “There’s nothing wrong with that guy in any weather after how he’s played tonight.”

But on the Vikes’ first drive in overtime, Peterson fumbled the ball. The Bears recovered it, and rammed a touchdown drive down the Vikings’ throats, winning the game.

The next time the Vikings came to Chicago, in 2010, to play another game in freezing weather, the story told by all national news writers was, again, “Favre can’t play in cold weather… Favre hasn’t won a game played in freezing temperatures in three years.”

You could chalk it up to what Matthew McConaughey, portraying Jack Lengyal, said in We Are Marshall: That “Winning is everything and nothing else matters.” But it’s far more likely that in the word of professional football, perception simply is not reality.

Perception trumps reality.

Advertisements

Tags: , , , , ,

About tharrington42

I teach English at an online school in Iowa. I am currently in the process of applying to grad schools. In my spare time I like to write, go biking, or lift weights.

2 responses to “Perception is Not Reality”

  1. Mason says :

    Do you mean, like, the perception that the QB is the most or only significant player? 😛 Something particularly tricky to remember is that most media is a constantly shifting group of individual humans whose job is to generate as much drama as possible to get attention. They are trying to create perception, even if that perception is a narrative that gives a character a defiant hero role within their constructed expectations.

    • tharrington42 says :

      Well, look at it this way. If the QB weren’t the most significant player, would I be able to name my blog after one? But yeah, you’re absolutely right. The media’s entire purpose, or at least it seems like this sometimes, is to always paint one person/group of people as the “hero” and another as the “bad guy.” I’m not entirely satisfied with how this post turned out, but what I was trying to talk about here was one example of this that seems particularly pronounced to me, but also that the narratives they create usually has less to do with the facts and more to do with the convenient story to tell at the time. When Favre was living high and playing like one of the best in the league, the narrative swings in his favor. When his play dropped off, he became the villain. But life doesn’t fit the media’s narratives, no matter how they might try.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: